J. M. Adam, F. Parisi, J. Sagaseta, and X. Lu, Research and practice on progressive collapse and robustness of building structures in the 21st century, Engineering Structures, vol.173, pp.122-149, 2018.

J. Agarwal, D. Blockley, and N. Woodman, Vulnerability of structural systems, Structural Safety, vol.25, pp.68-69, 2003.

J. Agarwal and J. England, Recent developments in robustness and relation with risk, Proceedings of the Institution of Civil Engineers -Structures and Buildings, vol.161, pp.183-188, 2008.

S. Alhafian, Seismic Progressive Collapse of Reinforced Concrete Frame Structures using the Applied Element Method, 2013.

R. Alsafadie, M. Hjiaj, and J. Battini, Three-dimensional formulation of a mixed corotational thin-walled beam element incorporating shear and warping deformation, 2011.
URL : https://hal.archives-ouvertes.fr/hal-01068892

, , vol.49, pp.523-533

, Minimum design loads and associated criteria for buildings and other structures, pp.7-16, 2016.

J. M. Anderies, M. A. Janssen, and E. Ostrom, A framework to analyze the robustness of social-ecological systems from an institutional perspective, 2004.

. Arcelormittal, Sections and Merchant Bars, 2018.

. Arcelormittal, Square hollow structural sections, 2018.

. Arup, Review of international research on structural robustness and disproportionate collapse. Department for Communities and Local Government, and Centre for the Protection of National Infrastructure, 2011.

E. Azéma, F. Radjaï, R. Peyroux, V. Richefeu, and G. Saussine, Short-time dynamics of a packing of polyhedral grains under horizontal vibrations, Eur. Phys. J. E, vol.26, pp.327-335, 2008.

A. Babazadeh, R. Burgueño, and P. F. Silva, P-? Effects on the Plastic Region of RC Bridge Columns: Closed-Form Solution, Journal of Structural Engineering, vol.142, 2016.

J. F. Baker, E. L. Williams, and D. Lax, The design of framed buildings against high explosive bombs, The Civil Engineer in War: Properties of Materials, Structures, Hydraulics, Tunnelling and Surveying, pp.80-112, 1948.


J. W. Baker, M. Schubert, and M. H. Faber, On the assessment of robustness, Structural Safety, vol.30, pp.253-267, 2008.

Y. Bao, S. K. Kunnath, S. El-tawil, and H. S. Lew, Macromodel-Based Simulation of Progressive Collapse: RC Frame Structures, Journal of Structural Engineering, vol.134, pp.7-1079, 2008.

Y. Bao, J. A. Main, H. S. Lew, and F. Sadek, Robustness Assessment of RC Frame Buildings under Column Loss Scenarios, Structures Congress, pp.988-1001, 2014.


M. C. Biggs, Constrained Minimization Using Recursive Quadratic Programming, pp.341-349, 1975.

F. Biondini, D. M. Frangopol, and S. Restelli, On Structural Robustness, Redundancy, and Static Indeterminacy, Structures Congress, pp.1-10, 2008.

J. Bleyer, Méthodes numériques pour le calcul à la rupture des structures de génie civil, 2015.

J. Bleyer and P. De-buhan, Yield surface approximation for lower and upper bound yield design of 3D composite frame structures, Computers & Structures, vol.129, pp.86-98, 2013.
URL : https://hal.archives-ouvertes.fr/hal-00870789

F. Bontempi, L. G. Giuliani, and K. Gkoumas, Handling the exceptions: Robustness assessment of a complex structural system, Proceedings of the 3rd international conference on structural engineering, mechanics and computation, pp.1747-1752, 2007.

W. Botte, R. Caspeele, D. Gouverneur, and L. Taerwe, Influence of membrane action on robustness indicators and a global resistance factor design, in: Bridge Maintenance, Safety, Management and Life Extension, pp.2038-2046, 2014.


C. Brett and Y. Lu, Assessment of robustness of structures: Current state of research, Frontiers of Structural and Civil Engineering, vol.7, pp.356-368, 2013.


T. Briscoe, Robust Parsing, Survey of the State of the Art in Human Language Technology, p.513, 1997.

J. Brozzetti, EUROCODE 3 CALCUL DES STRUCTURES EN ACIER. Partie 1-1, Règles générales et règles pour les bâtiments, 1996.

R. H. Byrd, J. C. Gilbert, and J. Nocedal, A trust region method based on interior point techniques for nonlinear programming, Math. Program, vol.89, pp.149-185, 2000.
URL : https://hal.archives-ouvertes.fr/inria-00073794


J. M. Carlson and J. Doyle, , 2002.

E. S. Cavaco, L. A. Neves, and J. R. Casas, On the robustness to corrosion in the life cycle assessment of an existing reinforced concrete bridge, Structure and Infrastructure Engineering, vol.14, pp.137-150, 2018.


Y. Chen, L. Huang, Y. Lu, L. Deng, and H. Tan, Assessment of Structural Robustness under Different Events according to Vulnerability, Journal of Performance, 2016.

J. Demonceau, Steel and composite building frames: sway response under conventional loading and development of membrane effects in beams further to an exceptional action, 2008.

J. Demonceau, M. D'antimo, and J. Jaspart, Robustness of steel structures subjected to a column loss scenario, Presented at the 6th International Symposium on Life-Cycle Civil Engineering, 2018.

C. A. Desprez, Analyse et Réduction de la Vulnérabilité Sismique des Structures Existantes : Renforcement par Collage de Tissus de Fibres de Carbone (TFC), 2010.

F. Dinu, I. Marginean, and D. Dubina, Experimental testing and numerical modelling of steel moment-frame connections under column loss, Engineering Structures, vol.151, pp.861-878, 2017.

D. Droogné, B. Botte, R. Caspeele, and L. Taerwe, Quantitative evaluation of Eurocode provisions with respect to structural robustness on the basis of numerical analysis of RC beams including membrane action. Presented at the Fib symposium, 2016.

D. Droogné, W. Botte, and R. Caspeele, A multilevel calculation scheme for risk-based robustness quantification of reinforced concrete frames, Engineering Structures, vol.160, pp.56-70, 2018.

M. El-hajj-diab, A. Orcesi, C. Desprez, and J. Bleyer, An embedded yield design approach within anon-linear analysis for structural modeling of progressive collapse. Presented at the RILEM spring convention and sustainable materials, systems and structures conference, 2019.

M. El-hajj-diab, A. Orcesi, C. Desprez, and J. Bleyer, A scenario-based procedure for structural robustness assessment, 2019.

, Guimarães, towards a resilient built environment -risk and asset management

H. M. Elsanadedy, T. H. Almusallam, Y. A. Al-salloum, and H. Abbas, Investigation of precast RC beam-column assemblies under column-loss scenario, Construction and Building Materials, vol.142, pp.552-571, 1990.

M. H. Faber, Risk and Safety in Civil Engineering, 2007.

M. H. Faber, M. A. Maes, D. Straub, and J. Baker, On the Quantification of Robustness of Structures, Materials Technology, vol.3, 2006.

, Douglas Faulkner Symposium on Reliability and Ultimate Strength of Marine Structures

H. S. Lew, J. A. Main, S. D. Robert, F. Sadek, and V. P. Chiarito, Performance of Steel Moment Connections under a Column Removal Scenario. I: Experiments, Journal of Structural Engineering, vol.139, pp.98-107, 2013.

S. Li, S. Shan, C. Zhai, and L. Xie, Experimental and numerical study on progressive collapse process of RC frames with full-height infill walls, Engineering Failure Analysis, vol.59, pp.57-68, 2016.

Y. Li, X. Lu, H. Guan, P. Ren, and L. Qian, Probability-based progressive collapseresistant assessment for reinforced concrete frame structures, Advances in Structural Engineering, vol.19, pp.1723-1735, 2016.

Z. X. Li, B. A. Izzuddin, and L. Vu-quoc, A 9-node co-rotational quadrilateral shell element, Comput Mech, vol.42, pp.873-884, 2008.

C. Liu, K. H. Tan, and T. C. Fung, Investigations of nonlinear dynamic performance of topand-seat with web angle connections subjected to sudden column removal, Engineering Structures, vol.99, pp.449-461, 2015.

X. Lu, X. Lin, and L. Ye, Simulation of Structural Collapse with Coupled Finite Element-Discrete Element Method, Computational Structural Engineering, pp.127-135, 2009.

R. Magalhães-de-souza, Force-based Finite Element for Large Displacement Inelastic Analysis of Frames, 2000.

J. Mazars, P. Kotronis, F. Ragueneau, and G. Casaux, Using multifiber beams to account for shear and torsion, Computer Methods in Applied Mechanics and Engineering, vol.195, pp.7264-7281, 2006.
URL : https://hal.archives-ouvertes.fr/hal-00115380

B. Meyer, Object-Oriented Software Construction, 1997.

, Minister of Housing and Local Government, 1970. The Building (Fifth Amendment) Regulations, 1970.

S. Mohammadkhani-shali, Study of systeme redundancy in bridges : failure machanism analysis using response surface methods, 2007.
URL : https://hal.archives-ouvertes.fr/pastel-00003313

A. Munjiza, T. Bangash, and N. W. John, The combined finite-discrete element method for structural failure and collapse, Engineering Fracture Mechanics, vol.71, pp.469-483, 2004.


A. M. Nafday, Consequence-based structural design approach for black swan events, Structural Safety, vol.33, pp.108-114, 2011.

N. F. En, Basis of structural design. Comité européen de Normalisation (CEN), 1990.

N. F. En, Eurocode 1, Actions on structures, Part 1-1: General actions -Densities, self weight, imposed loads for buildings, p.227, 1991.

D. T. Pham, Analyse par le calcul à la rupture de la stabilité au feu des panneaux en béton armé de grandes dimensions, 2014.


K. Qian and B. Li, Effects of Masonry Infill Wall on the Performance of RC Frames to Resist Progressive Collapse, Journal of Structural Engineering, vol.143, 2017.

K. Qian and B. Li, Dynamic and residual behavior of reinforced concrete floors following instantaneous removal of a column, Engineering Structures, vol.148, pp.175-184, 2017.


C. T. Ross, Elastic Instability, Encyclopedia of Materials: Science and Technology, pp.2425-2427, 2001.

J. Rousseau, Modélisation numérique du comportement dynamique de structures sous impact sévère avec un couplage éléments discrets / éléments finis, 2009.

F. Sadek, S. El-tawil, and H. S. Lew, Robustness of Composite Floor Systems with Shear Connections: Modeling, Simulation, and Evaluation, Journal of Structural Engineering, vol.134, pp.11-1717, 2008.

F. Sadek, J. A. Main, H. S. Lew, and Y. Bao, Testing and Analysis of Steel and Concrete Beam-Column Assemblies under a Column Removal Scenario, Journal of Structural Engineering, vol.137, pp.881-892, 2011.

J. Salençon, Yield design, Mechanical engineering and solid mechanics series, 2013.

L. Wiley,

M. Sasani, Response of a reinforced concrete infilled-frame structure to removal of two adjacent columns. Engineering Structures, vol.30, pp.2478-2491, 2008.


M. Sasani, A. Kazemi, S. Sagiroglu, and S. Forest, Progressive Collapse Resistance of an Actual 11-Story Structure Subjected to Severe Initial Damage, Journal of Structural Engineering, vol.137, pp.893-902, 2011.

M. Sasani and S. Sagiroglu, Gravity Load Redistribution and Progressive Collapse Resistance of 20-Story Reinforced Concrete Structure following Loss of Interior Column, Structural Journal, vol.107, 2010.

M. Sasani and S. Sagiroglu, Progressive Collapse Resistance of Hotel San Diego, Journal of Structural Engineering, vol.134, pp.3-478, 2008.

M. Sasani, A. Werner, and A. Kazemi, Bar fracture modeling in progressive collapse analysis of reinforced concrete structures, Engineering Structures, vol.33, pp.401-409, 2011.


H. Scholz, P-Delta Effect Under Repeated Loading, Journal of Structural Engineering, vol.116, pp.733-9445, 1990.

E. H. Seck, Contribution au développement d'outils analytiques et numériques pour quantifier et qualifier la robustesse des structures (Contribution to the development of analytical and numerical tools to quantify and qualify the robustness of structures), 2018.

. Paris-lumières-university,

. Sétra, Robustesse des ouvrages, in: Maîtrise Des Risques-Application Aux Ouvrages d'art. Service d'études sur les transports, les routes et leurs aménagements, pp.61-88, 2013.

. Sétra, Robustesse des ouvrages, 2013.

S. Shan, S. Li, S. Xu, and L. Xie, Experimental study on the progressive collapse performance of RC frames with infill walls, Engineering Structures, vol.111, pp.80-92, 2016.


J. E. Slotine and W. Li, Applied Nonlinear Control, 1991.

B. I. Song, K. A. Giriunas, and H. Sezen, Progressive collapse testing and analysis of a steel frame building, Journal of Constructional Steel Research, vol.94, pp.76-83, 2014.


U. Starossek and M. Haberland, Measures of Structural Robustness -Requirements and Applications, in: Structures Congress, pp.1-10, 2008.

S. M. Stinger and S. L. Orton, Experimental Evaluation of Disproportionate Collapse Resistance in Reinforced Concrete Frames, Structural Journal, vol.110, 2013.

P. Stylianidis, Progressive collapse response of steel and composite buildings, 2011.

R. Sun, Z. Huang, and I. W. Burgess, Progressive collapse analysis of steel structures under fire conditions, Engineering Structures, vol.34, pp.400-413, 2012.


S. S. Sunder, R. G. Gann, W. L. Grosshandler, H. S. Lew, R. W. Bukowski et al., Final report on the collapse of the World Trade Center towers :: federal building and fire safety investigation of the World Trade Center disaster (No. NIST NCSTAR 1), 2005.

H. Tagel-din, High Fidelity Modeling of Building Collapse with Realistic Visualization of Resulting Damage and Debris Using the Applied Element Method, 2009.

H. Tagel-din and K. Meguro, Applied element method for simulation of nonlinear materials: theory and application for RC structures, International Journal of the Japan Society of Civil Engineers, vol.17, pp.137-148, 2000.

G. Taguchi and S. Chowdhury, Robust engineering -learn how to boost quality while reducing costs and time to market, 1999.

T. Takeda, M. A. Sozen, and N. N. Neilsen, Reinforced concrete response to simulated earthquakes 96, pp.2557-2573, 1970.

, Design of buildings to resist progressive collapse, 2009.

C. A. Vidalis, Improving the resistance to progressive collapse of steel and composite frames, 2014.

H. Vincent, M. Arquier, J. Bleyer, and P. De-buhan, Yield design based numerical analysis of three-dimensional reinforced concrete structures, 2017.
URL : https://hal.archives-ouvertes.fr/hal-01738638

A. G. Vlassis, B. A. Izzuddin, A. Y. Elghazouli, and D. A. Nethercot, Progressive collapse of multi-storey buildings due to sudden column loss-Part II: Application. Engineering Structures, vol.30, pp.1424-1438, 2008.


T. Vrouwenvelder, Treatment of risk and reliability in the Eurocodes, Proceedings of the Institution of Civil Engineers -Structures and Buildings, vol.161, pp.209-214, 2008.

X. D. Vu, Vulnérabilité des ouvrages en béton sous impact : Caractérisation, modélisation, et validation, 2013.

R. A. Waltz, J. L. Morales, J. Nocedal, and D. Orban, An interior algorithm for nonlinear optimization that combines line search and trust region steps, Math. Program, vol.107, pp.391-408, 2006.

Y. Xiao, S. Kunnath, F. W. Li, Y. B. Zhao, H. .. Lew et al., Collapse test of threestorey half-scale reinforced concrete frame building, ACI Structural Journal, vol.112, pp.429-438, 2015.

B. Xue and J. Le, Stochastic Computational Model for Progressive Collapse of Reinforced Concrete Buildings, Journal of Structural Engineering, vol.142, p.4016031, 2016.

B. Xue and J. Le, Simplified energy-based analysis of collapse risk of reinforced concrete buildings, Structural Safety, vol.63, pp.47-58, 2016.


W. Yi, Q. He, Y. Xiao, and S. K. Kunnath, Experimental Study on Progressive Collapse-Resistant Behavior of Reinforced Concrete Frame Structures, Structural Journal, vol.105, 2008.

H. Yin and G. Shi, Finite element analysis on the seismic behavior of fully prefabricated steel frames, Engineering Structures, vol.173, pp.28-51, 2018.


J. Yu and K. H. Tan, Structural Behavior of Reinforced Concrete Frames Subjected to Progressive Collapse, Structural Journal, vol.114, 2017.

J. Yu and K. H. Tan, Special Detailing Techniques to Improve Structural Resistance against Progressive Collapse, Journal of Structural Engineering, vol.140, 2014.

J. Yu and K. Tan, Experimental and numerical investigation on progressive collapse resistance of reinforced concrete beam column sub-assemblages, Engineering Structures, vol.55, pp.90-106, 2013.

R. Zandonini, N. Baldassino, and F. Freddi, Robustness of steel-concrete flooring systems, 2014.