Transcatheter aortic valve implantation (TAVI) in Germany 2008-2014: on its way to standard therapy for aortic valve stenosis in the elderly?, EuroIntervention, vol.11, issue.9 ,
DOI : 10.4244/EIJY15M09_11
Percutaneous transcatheter implantation of an aortic valve prosthesis for calcific aortic stenosis, ACC Current Journal Review, vol.12, issue.2, pp.3006-8204, 2002. ,
DOI : 10.1016/S1062-1458(03)00094-1
5-year outcomes of transcatheter aortic valve replacement or surgical aortic valve replacement for high surgical risk patients with aortic stenosis (PARTNER 1): a randomised controlled trial, The Lancet, vol.385, issue.9986, pp.2477-84, 2015. ,
DOI : 10.1016/S0140-6736(15)60308-7
5-Year Outcomes After Transcatheter Aortic Valve Implantation With CoreValve Prosthesis 5-year outcome after transcatheter aortic valve implantation, JACC Cardiovascular interventions J Am Coll Cardiol, vol.8617, pp.1084-91413, 2013. ,
Multicenter Evaluation of a Next-Generation Balloon-Expandable Transcatheter Aortic Valve, on its way to standard therapy for aortic valve stenosis in the elderly, pp.2235-2278, 2008. ,
DOI : 10.1016/j.jacc.2014.09.026
Transcatheter aortic valve implantation: a revolution in the therapy of elderly and high-risk patients with severe aortic stenosis, J Geriatr Cardiol, vol.14, issue.3, pp.204-221, 2017. ,
5-year outcomes of transcatheter aortic valve replacement or surgical aortic valve replacement for high surgical risk patients with aortic stenosis (PARTNER 1): a randomised controlled trial, The Lancet, vol.385, issue.9986 ,
DOI : 10.1016/S0140-6736(15)60308-7
5-Year Outcomes After Transcatheter Aortic Valve Implantation With CoreValve Prosthesis, JACC: Cardiovascular Interventions, vol.8, issue.8, pp.1084-91, 2015. ,
DOI : 10.1016/j.jcin.2015.03.024
5-Year Outcome After Transcatheter Aortic Valve Implantation, Journal of the American College of Cardiology, vol.61, issue.4, pp.413-422, 2013. ,
DOI : 10.1016/j.jacc.2012.11.010
Multicenter Evaluation of a Next-Generation Balloon-Expandable Transcatheter Aortic Valve, Journal of the American College of Cardiology, vol.64, issue.21, pp.2235-2278, 2014. ,
DOI : 10.1016/j.jacc.2014.09.026
First look at long-term durability of transcatheter heart valves: Assessment of valve function up to 10-years after implantation, EuroPCR, vol.78, 2016. ,
The effects of transcatheter valve crimping on pericardial leaflets. The Annals of thoracic surgery, pp.1260-1266, 2014. ,
Traumatic leaflet injury during the use of percutaneous valves: a comparative study of balloon-and selfexpandable valved stents. European journal of cardio-thoracic surgery : official journal of the European Association for Cardio-thoracic Surgery, pp.488-93, 2013. ,
Evidence of leaflet injury during percutaneous aortic valve deployment. European journal of cardio-thoracic surgery : official journal of the European Association for Cardio-thoracic Surgery, pp.257-266, 2011. ,
Crimping may affect the durability of transcatheter valves: an experimental analysis. The Annals of thoracic surgery Leaflet Calcification and Matrix Damage Due to Transcatheter Heart Valve Crimping, Circulation, vol.92132, issue.12, pp.155-601, 2011. ,
Assessing anticalcification treatments in bioprosthetic tissue by using the New Zealand rabbit intramuscular model, Comp Med, vol.59, issue.3, pp.266-71, 2009. ,
)65'0!9?!5$)6A.)5/'5'$!5!25)60)$0#c), 6#.)*!5'A5#6%!3F!('$#.)$0#4@!F3$! @)64F).54$#6%!($3A5NU,! ke4@)6! A'@#*46)$! .)$0#).! =)*='! $'@30'*#6%! 9?! ).5#=)5'0! .'**A! F$3@! F'54A! 53! )04*5T! #@(*#.)5#36A! F3$! (3A56)5 ,
!24$%!aSYLUT!7:N;O7:6! )60! h,! b,! e)A'6`)@! Y7, 5A! 3F! 5$)6A 4A'! 3F! ('$.45)6'34A! =)*='AT! )! .3@()$)5#='! A540?! 3F! 9)**336O! )60! A'*FO'J()60)9*'! =)*='0!A5'65A)9*'! )3$5#.! =)*='! )60! #6#5#)*! $'A4*5A! a#5/! #@(*)65)5#36! 9?! .)5/'5'$!5'./6#M4'!#6!.*3A'0!./'A5!(#%A,k!I4$!e')$5!h @3$(/3*3%?! 3F! 5/'! 63$@)*! )3$5#.! =)*='! )A! .3@()$'0! a#5=#6%! 5a3! *')F*'5A,k!h!B/3$).!P)$0#3=)A.!24$%!aUY8UT!8N:O8N<,! D$94A5#6#\!I,\!b,!h36'A\!-,!",!b3A'A\!I,!I,!I#093\!-,!h,!P)$$3**!)60!Z,!h,!C'$$)6A!Y7[SLU,!kb30#F#.)5#36!9?! 5/'! e)6.3.`! BN! ($3.'AA! 3F! .)*.#F#.)5#36! 3F! 9#3($3A5/'5#.! .)$0#).! =)*='A! #@(*)65'0! #6! A/''(,k! D@! h! P)$0#3*!NRY[UT!78SSO78 ,
!)3$5#.!=)*='o,k! E)6%'69, )$('65#'$!)60!h,!E)6%*3#A!Y7[NNU,!kne'5'$3*3%34A!5$)6A(*)65)5#36!3F!53@93A#A!#6!.)$35#0!)$5'$?!)5/'$3A.*'$3A#A,k!D$5'$3J?)()5#5'! F3$@)5#36!#604.'0!9?!.)*.#4@O(/3A(/3*#(#0O(/3A(/)5'!.3@(*'J'A3559)4'$! )60! h7<U,! kC)A5! Z)*='! "'%'6'$)5#36! )F5'$! B$)6A.)5/'5'$!D3$5#.!Z)*='!-'(*).'@'65!#6!)!e'@30#)*?A#A!+)5#'65,k!h34$6)*!3F!P)$0#3*3%?!)60!P*#6#.)*! -'A')$./!NY8UT!L,! ! ! 7LQ! ,
45!H)5'A!)60!b,!-,!b336!Y:;;QU,!kB A5$'AAfA5$)#6! )60! F)5#%4'! 9'/)=#34$! 3F! %*45)$)*030)663\!cc)\! h,! e)6.3)60!b,!e)40'!Y:;7<U,!k25)60)$0#c! b4*/3**)60! )60! b,! l'9'$! Y:;;QU,! kB:;7;U,!ke'@30?6)@#.!F).53$A!)FF'.5#6%!5, 9#.4A(#0!)3$5#.!=))*! )3$5#.! 9#3($3A5/'5#.! =)*='AT! )! .36A'6A4A! A5)5'@'65! F$3@! 5/'! I4$3(')6! DAA3.#)5#36! 3F! +'$.45)6'34A!P)$0#3=)A.4*)$!R65'$='65#36A!YID+PRU!'603$A'0!9I4$3(')6!23.#'5?!3F!P)$0#3*3%?! YI2PU! )60! 5/'! I4$3(')6! DAA3.#)5#36! F3$! P)$0#3OB/3$).#.! 24$%'$?! YIDPB2U,k! I4$! h! P)$0#35/3$).! 24F)5'!3F!=)*=4*)$!9#3($3A5/'A#A,k!P#$.4*)5#36! GMGY7[UT!:;S8O:;SL,! P)$('65#'$\! D,! )60! 2,! P)$('65#'$! Y:;;8U,! b'5/30A! F3$! 5$')5#6%! #@(*)65)9*'! 9#3*3%#.)*! 5#AA4'A! 53! @#5#%)5'!5/'!.)*.#F#.)5#36!5/'$'3F!)60!9#3($3A5/'5#.!)$5#.*'A!5$')5'0!9?!A4./!@'5/30A,!q2D\!I0a)$0A! E#F'A.#'6.'A!P3$(3$)5#36,!4%!QbNQGbaSV!2G9#)6#\!h,!C3$@)6\!h,3%$)F5A,! l#5/! ()$5#.4*)$! $'F'$'6.'! 53! 5/'!5$')5@'65!3F!.36%'6#5)*!=)*='!@)*F3$@)5#36A,k!h!B/3$).!P)$0#3=)A.!24$!)60!G,!i34AA'F!Y7[SLU,!kB'./6#M4'A!F3$!($'='65#36! 3F!.)*.#F#.)5#36!3F!=)*=4*)$!9#3($3A5/'A'A,k!P#$.4*)5#36!SVY8!+5!:UT!R7NQO7NS,! P)$('65#'$\!26\!E,!h,!r4#65'$3!)60!B,!e,!l#5c'*!Y7[[QU,!kP)*.#4@! @#5#%)5#36!#6!9#3($3A5/'5#.!5#AA4'A!9?!#$36!($'5$')5@'65T!5/'!./)**'6%'!3F!#$36!*')./#6%,k!D66!B/3$).! 24$%!QVY:!24((*UT, p.88 ,
! P46)6)6\! X,! b)$5#6'5! )60, )5! 5$')5@'65! @#5#%)5'A! .)*.#F#.)5#36! 3F! =)*=4*)$! 9#3($3A5/'A'A,k! D66! B/3$).! 24$%!QQYN!245#'A!3F!/')5O5$')5'0!=)*=4*)$!9#3@9'$A\!h,!Y:;7LU,!k+$3A5/'5#.!/')$5!=)*='A,k!R65!h!P*#6!+$).5!QUY7;UT!7::<O7:8 ,
UT!7()5#'65A,k!-#A`!b)6)%!e')*5, F#J)5#36!36!F46.5#36,k!I4$!h!P)$0#35/3$).!24$%!Q!%I<<C!GT!2:QO8:W!0#A.4AA#36!288, )60! '.363@#.! 345.3@'A! )F5'$! A4$%#.)*! )3$5#.! =)*='! $'(*).'@'65! #6! b'0#.)$'!)**336O'J()60)9*'!=)*='0!A5'65A!)$'!$'A(36A#9*'!F3$!5/'!#6.$')A'!#6!5$)4*#.! .3604.5)6.'!3F!*')F*'5A,k!I4$!h!P)$0#35/3$).!24$%!TTYNUT!7;LQO7;Q ,
4*\! i,! =36! X)**?! )60! e,! e,! 2, 3@94A! F3$@)5#36! F3**3a#6%! 5$)6A.).)*.#F#.)5#36T!.3@()$#6%!('$#.)$0#)*!='$A4A!(3$.#6'!9#3($3A5/'A'A,k!h!e')$5! Z)*='!"#A!SYLUT!L7D@)5O2)653A\!E,!b,!X'6#5'c\!h,!b'a)\!+,!h#@'6'cOr4'='03\!2,!D*6)AA'$\!X,!i)$.#)! "'*!X*)6, p.4 ,
cc)\!2,!X*'#c#FF'$!)60!-,!E)6%'!Y:;7QU,! k25$4.54$)*! =)*='! 0'5'$#3$)5#36! L! ?')$A! )F5'$! 5$)6A.)5/'5'$! )3$5#.! =)*='! $'(*).'@'65T! #@)%#6%! )60! (, )5#36,k! P#$.4*)5#36! GVTY7NUT! 7SS7O 7SS8#F#.)5#36!q2D\!I0a)$0A!E#F'A.#'6.'A!P3$(3$)5#36! ,!4%SaSMRSQ!2G,! "46.)6\!D,!P,!)60!",!X34%/6'$!Y7[[SU,!kIFF'.5!3F!0?6)@#.!%*45)$)*06#A@A!3F!.)*.#F#.)5#36!)6\!b,!X)$9)65#\!b,!2'#0@)6\!D,\!+,!X*)6`'\!-,!m)3\!-,! X336'\! 2,! E)4.`\! 2,! E#./5'6A5'#6\! ",! l330\! D,! P$#9#'$! )60! h,! l'99! Y:;7NU,! C#$A5! *33`! )5! *36%O5'$@! 04$)9#*#5?! 3F! 5$)6A.)5/'5'$! /')$5! =)*='AT! DAA'AA@'65! 3F! =)*='! F46.5#36! 4(! 53! 7;O?')$A! )F5'$! #@(*)65)5#36,!I4$3+P-!:;7N,!+)*)#A!0'A! ,
534$6'4$\! I,! E)6A).! )60! D,! b'00)5A,!X#3@)5'$#)*A!2.#'6.'!)60!I6%#6''$#6%,!-,!+#%6)5'**3\!R6B, 39'$5A!Y7[S<U,!k+)5/3*3%?!3F!9#3($3A5/'5#.! .)$0#).!=)*='A,k!e4@!+)5/3*i330@)6!)60!D,!P)$('65#'$! Y7[S:U,! kP)*.#F#.)5#36A! 3F! .)$0#).! =)*='! 9#3! b'4$#A\! h,! m('$@)6\! i,! "'! Z#AA./'$\! +,! e'$#>%'$A! )60! I,! Z'$9 ,
53$! )60, =)5'0! 04$#6%! 6'3#65#@)! F3$@)5#36! #6! $)5! )$5'$#'A! )60! #A! )! 63='*! .3@(36'65! 3F! /4@)6!)5/'$3A.*'$35#.!(*)M4'A,k!h!P*#6!R6='A5!aMYLUT!7NSNO7N[N,! i#$)$035\!h,!b,!Y7[[;U,!+$'='65#36!3F!($3A5/'A#A!.)*.#F#.)5#36\!X#3@'0#.)*!"'A#%6\!R6.,!4%!TbaSQbSRR!+,! i3*3@9\! i,! Y7[S<U,! kP365$3**'0! $'*')A'! 3F! 0#(/3A(/36)5'A6\! h,! b,! i#$)$035! )60! -,! D,! i4?536! Y7[[:U,!kP)*.#F#.)5#36!3F!(3$.#6'!=)*='AT!)!A4..'AAF4*!6'a!@'5/30!3F!)65#@#6'$)*#c)5#36,k!D66!B/3$).! 24$%!NRY:UT!:;<O:7QW!0#A.4AA#36!:7N,! i$)60'OD)*)9$3\! Z,!3\! D,! P)*)9$3\! m8U,! kE3AA! 3F! ./360$3#5#6!NOA4*F)5'!)60!/?)*4$36)6!F$3@!F)#*'0!(3$.#6'!9#3($3A5/'5#.!=)*='A,k!h!X#3@'0!b)5'$87U,!kB3(3%$)(/#.!D6)53@?!) R@@'\! +,! D$45)\! Z,! X355)$#\! I,! X'6='6453\! P,! B)@94$#63\! DB30)$3\!I,!"#!2#@36'\!D,!R60'*#.)53\!",! i#)66)cc3\! P,! 2%$3#! )60! P,! B)@94$#63! Y:;7NU,! kC34$O?')$! 04$)9#*#5?! 3F! .*#6#.)*! )60! /)'@30?6)@#.! 345.3@'A! 3F! 5$)6A.)5/'5'$! )3$5#.! =)*='! #@(*)65)5#36! a#560#6%! P3$'Z)*=',k! I4$3R65'$='65#36!GMYSUT!'7;87O'7;8S,! e)@@'$@'#A5'$\!H,\!i,!H,!2'5/#\!l,!i,!e'60'$$#)6!)60!2,!e,!-)/#@533*)!Y:;;;U,! k_45.3@'A! 7Q! ?')$A! )F5'$! =)*='! $'(*).'@'65! a#5/! )! @'./)6#.)*! ='$A4A! )! 9#3($3A5/'5#.! =)*='T! F#6)*! $'(3$5!3F!5/'!Z'5'$)6A!DFF)#$A!$)603@#c'0!5$#)*,k!h!D@!P3**!P)$0#3*!RQYLUT!77Q:O77QS ,
39'?!9#60#6%!3F!I=)6A!9*4'!53!.3**)%'6!)60!'*), ! kB')$A! #6! 9#3($3A5/'5#.! /')$5!=)*='!*')F*'5A!a#5/345!.)*.#F#.!0'%'6'$)5#36,k!h!e')$5!Z)*='!"#A!NY7UT!8QO8[,! e'#6*'\!e,!)60!)6)*?A#A,k!h!X#3@'0!b)5'$!-'A!RaY:UT!:7QO::7,! e#*9'$5\!2,D@#c4`)!)60!e,!_c)a)!Y7[[[U,!kB/'!($#@)$?!.)*.#F#.)5#36!#6! 936'A!F3**3aA!$'@3=)*!3F!0'.3$#6!)60!F4A#36!3F!.3**)%'6!F#9$#*A,k!h!X36'!b#6'$!-'A!GTY:UT!:<8O:S;,! e4)6%\!i,!)60!2)6A\! 2,! l,! X3?.'\! b,! h36'A! )60! l,! P,! -39'$5A! Y7[S7)U,! k25$4.54$'! )60! .*)AA#F#.)5#36! 3F! .4A()*! 5')$A! )60! ('$F3$)5#36A! #6! (3$.#6'! 9#3($3A5/'5#.! .)$0#).! =)*='A! #@(*)65'0! #6! ()5#'65A,k!D@!h!P)$'$$)6A\!b,!h36'A\!2,!l,!X3?.'\!_,!H)a)6)@#!)60!l,!P,!-39'$5A!Y7[S;U,!ke#A53*3%# ,
! kb)5$#J! @'5)**3($35'#6)A'O:!#A!)AA3.#)5'0!a#5! b3/*'$\! 8$0! )60! -,! h,! E'=?! Y:;;8U,! k+$3%$'AA#36! 3F! )3$5#.! =)*='! A5'63A#AT!BiCO9'5)7!#A!($'A'65!#6!.)*.#F#'0!)3$5#40'$3\! h,! b,! i)$.#)O+)'c\! h,! X4>)6! )60, #F#.)5#36! 3F! (3$.#6'! =)*='! 5#AA4'! 9?! A'*'.5#='! *#(#0! $'@3=)*,k!X#3@)5'$#)*A!GNY7;UT!S7QOS:;,! h3$%'Oe'$$'$3\! I,\! +,! C'$6)60'c\! b,! i45#'$$'c! )60! h,! E,! P)A5#**3O_*#=)$'A! Y7[[7U,! k2540?! 3F! 5/'! .)*.#F#.)5#36! 3F! 93=#6'! ('$#.)$0#4@T! )6)*?A#A! 3F! 5/'! #@(*#.)5#36! 3F! *#(#0A! )60! ($35'3%*?.)6A,k! X#3@)5'$#)*A!GMY<UT!NS8ONS[,! ! ! 7L ,
45)6'34A! 5$)6AF'@3$)*! )3$5#65)5#36T! )! 0#FF4A#36Oa!)60!+,!5,! #6='A5#%)53$A! Y:;7QU,! kQO?')$! 345.3@'A! 3F! 5$)6A.)5/'5'$! )3$5#.! =)*='! $'(*).'@'65! .3@()$'0! a#5/! A5)60)$0! 5$')5@'65! F3$! ()5#'65A! a#5/! #63('$)9*'! )3$5#.! A5'63A#A! Y+D-BGI-! 7UT! )! $)603@#A'0! .365$3**'0!5$#)*,k!E)6)60!A5)60)$0!5 =)*='AT! )6! 'J('$#@'65)*! )6)*?A#A, 5#=)53$!3F!64C365)6)\!6#.)*!0'%$)0)5#36!3F!9#3*3%#.)*!/')$5!=)*='!5#AA4'!#604.'0!9?!*3a! 0#)@'5'$!.$#@(#6%T!)6!')$*?!)AA'AA@'65)F*'5! F*'J4$'!#6!9#3($3A5/'5#.!=)*='A!@3465'0!36!$#%#0!)60!'J()6A#*'!A5'65A,k!h!X#3@'./!MQYSUT![:[O[L8 D904**)! )60! h,! b,! E''! Y7[[[U,! kX#)J#)*! @'./)6#.)*fA5$4.54$)*!'FF'.5A!3F!'M4#9#)J#)*!A5$)#6!04$#6%!.$3AA*#6`#6%!3F!93=#6'!('$#.)$0#)*!J'63%$)F5! @)5'$#)*A,k!X#3@)5'$#)*A!MVY:UT!78<O7Q8,! E)6#$\! m,! )60! m,! P,! C46%! Y7[<L)U,! kBa3O0#@'6A#36)*! @'./)6#.)*! ($3('$5#'A! 3F! $)99#5! A`#6,! R,! IJ('$#@'65)*!A?A5'@,k!h!X#3@'./!SY7UT!:[O8L,! E)6#$\! m,! )60! m,! P,! C46%! Y7[<L9U,! kBa3O0#@'6A#36)*! @'./)6#.)*! ($3('$5#'A! 3F! $)99#5! A`#6,! RR,! IJ('$#@'65)*!$'A4*5A,k!h!X#3@'./!SY:UT!7<7O7S:,A#3*3%#.)*!=)$#)9*'A!#6=3*='0!#6!/')$5!=)*='!A49A5#545'!.)*.#F#.)5#36,k!IJ('$5!_(#6! X#3*!B/'$!aYSUT!7, pp.60-63 ,
6!)60!I, #F#.)5#36!#6! (3$.#6'!)60!93=#6'!J'63%$)F5!@)5'$#)*A,k!B$)6A!D@!23.!D$5#F!R65'$6!_$%) +#./)$0\! 2,! H)()0#)\! B, p.79 ,
O0'('60'65!'FF'.5! 3F! %*45)$)*0'/?0'! 36! 5/'! 5'60'66AA36! )60! +,! 5,! #6='A5#%)53$A! Y:;7QU,! kQO?')$! 345.3@'A! 3F! 5$)6A.)5/'5'$! )3$5#$)=)$5?, )$5!=)*='!()5/39#3*3%?,k!D@!h!+)5/3*#AA@)6\!2,!H)()0#)\!I,!b)6)AA'\!A49.45)6'34A!$)5!@30'*T!)6)*?A#A!3F!=)$#)5#36A!#6!#@(*)65!A#5'!)60!.4A()*!M4)0$)65A,k!h! X#3@'0!b)5'$!-'A!TNY8UT!:;[O:78,! b)$5#6\! P,! )60! l,! 246! Y:;78U,! kb30'*#6%! 3F! *36%O5'$@! F)5#%4'! 0)@)%'! 3F! A3F5! 5#AA4'! a#5/! A5$'AA! A3F5'6#6%!)60!('$@)6'65!A'5!'FF'.5A,k!X#3@ 63$@)*!)60!)963$@)*!5$#.4A(#0!=)*=',k!P)$0#3*!m346%!GQ!%I<<C!RT!LO77,! b)A5'$7U,! kP3@()$)5#='! .*#6#.)*! 345.3@'A! a#5/! 25,! h40'! b'0#.)*\! b'05$36#.! e)**! )60! P)$93b'0#.A! @'./)6#.)*! /')$5! =)*='A,k! h! e')$5! Z))@#.! @'./)6#.)*! ./)$).5'$#A5#.A! 3F! #65).5! )60! A5$4.54$)**?! @30#F#'0! 93=#6'! ('$#.)$0#)*! 5#AA4'A,k! h! X#3@'./! RUYLUT! <N7O <NS,! b'603c)OG3='*4#./O-30$#%4'c\!I,!h3$%'Oe'$$'$3\!C,!h,!-3>3\!i,!Z,!i4#6')!)60! h,!E,!b)5, pp.3-34 ,
($35'#6A! X\! Y)U\! )60! I! )..4@4*)5'! #6! 5, =4*)$!)3$5#.!A5'63A#A,k!D$5'$4@4*)5#36!3F!B!*?@(/3.?5'A!)60!'J($'AA#36!3F!#65'$*'4`#6O:!$'.'(53$A!#6!636$/'4@)5#.!A5'635# ,
$5!P36A'6A4A!"'.#A#36!+)5/a)?!F3$!B$)6A.)5/'5'$!D3$5#.!Z)*='! -'(*).'@'65!#6!5, #c)5#36!3F! 5/'! ')$*?! *'A#36! 3F! V0'%'6'$)5#='V! =)*=4*)$! )3$5#.! A5'63A#A,! e#A53*3%#.)*! )60! #@@463/#A53./'@#.)*! A540#'A,k!P#$.4*)5#36!aVY0#3=)A.4*)$!@3$5)*#5?!)60!@3$9#0#5?!#6!53@()$#A36! 3F! )! X>3 #6! 3A5'39*)A5#.! 0#FF'$'65#)5#36! 3F! @)$$3a! A5$3@)*! .'**A,k! h! X36'! b#6'$!-'A!GSY77UT!7[, pp.3-3 ,
#6#\! +,! Z'6)\! 2,! b)65'$3! )60! C,! b,! b365, )$0#3=)A.! q*5$)A3460!MRY:UT!Q[ON)54$'! 5'6036AOO)! .3@(45)5#36)*!A540?!F$3@!@3*'.4*)$!53!@#.$3A5$4.54$)A#.)*! ($3('$5#'A! 3F! 93=#6'! ('$#.)$0#4@T!)!A540?!3F!5!l#*`#6A36!)60!-,!e,!D60'$A36!Y7[S[U,!kB/'!@'0#)*!()(#**)$?!@4A.*'!.3@(*'J! ,
! b463cOP/)(4*#! )60! b,! P)$03! Y7, F3$@)5#36!3F!.36%'6#5)*!9#.4A(#0!)3$5#.!=)*='A! #6!2?$#)6!/)@A5'$A,k!D6)5!-'.!MTTYLUT!L ,
3%*?.)6O5?('! R! .3**)%'6! F#9$#*! #65'$), 5#36A! #6! 936'! )60! 636O .)*.#F?#6%!.366'.5#='!5#AA4'A,k!X#3A.#!-'(!NY7UT!<7OS7 ,
A($'A! )60! +,! b)5, *)@@)5#36! )60! 0'%'6'$)5#36! 3F! 9#3($3A5 ,
@(! )60! G,! -,! Z?)=)/)$'! Y:;;8)U,! kIJ5$).'**4*)$! @)5$#J! 0'%$)0#6%! '6c?@'A! )$'! )5#='! #6! (3$.#6'! A5'65*'AA! )3$5#.! 9#3($3A55! =)*='A,k! h! X#3@'0! b)5'$5! =)*='! 0'%'6'$)5#36,k! h! e')$5!Z), )60!4*5$)A5$4.54$))$0#4@!)60!5#AA4'!A'*'.5#36!F3$!9#3($3A5/'5#.!/')$5!=)*='A,k!h!X#3@'0!b)5'$0=)$! Y:;7QU,! kE')F*'5! P)*.#F#.)5#36! )60! b)5$#J! ")@)%'! "4'! 53! B$)6A.)5/'5'$! e')$5!Z)*='!P$#@(#6%,k!P#$.4*)5#36!GRMY24((*!8UT!714$)`3aA`#\)A)OG#.35'$)\!G,!l'$6'$\!2,6#%!)60! P,! e)@@'$A5#6%*! Y:;7LU,! kP3$'Z)*='! 0'%'6'$)5#36! a#5O#6O=)*='!#@(*)65)5#36,k!hDPP!P)$0#3=)A.!R65'$=!SY<UT!'<7O<:,! 2#c'*)60\ P46)6)6\! G,! H#$9?\! D,! e)a*'?\! 2,! B,! b40#'! )60! -,! i,! e)='$`)@(!Y:;7LU,!kD%'!0'('60'65!0#FF'$'6.'A!#6!.3**)%'6!)*#%6@'65!3F!%*45)$)*0'/?0'!F#J'0!93=#6'! ('$#.)$0#4@,k!X#3@'0!-'A!R65!MVGTT!7S[7[<,! 230'`\!h,\!X,!i)6AA!)60!b,!",!b.H''!Y:;;;U,!k_A5'3(365#6,k!P$#5!-'=!_$)*!X#3*!b'0!GGY8UT!:<[O8 23#6#\!m,\!B,!2)*3!)60!h,!2)55)!Y:;;8U,!kD6%#3%'6'A#A!#A!#6=3*='0!#6!5/'!()5/3%'6'A#A!3F!636$/'4@)5#.! ,
\!)60!)..'*'$)5'0!.)*.#F#.)5#36,k!h!B/3$)! P)$0#3=)A.!24, k2#@4*)5'0!'**#(5#.)*!9#3($3A5/'5#.!=)*='!0'F3$@)5#36T!#@(*#.)5#36A! F3$!)A?@@'5$#.!5$)6A.)5/'5'$!=)*='!0'(*3?@'65,k!h!X#3@'./!TRY7NUT!8;SQO8;[;,! ! ! 7QL! ,
5'$3%$)F5!/')$5!=)*='!9#3@)5'$#)*A!53!@30'$)5'!.?.*#.!*3)0#6%,k!h!X#3@'0!b)5C)0?'6!Y:;;QU,!kb)5$#J!@'5)**3($35'#6)A'A!#6!.3$36)$?!)$5, #6#.)*! )60! 5/'$)('45#.! #@(*#.)5#36A! )60! ()5/3*3%#.)*! A#%6#F#.)6.',k! P4$$! b'0! P/'@! GMYSUT!, p.7 ,
! )60! B,! b,! b)003J! Y:;77U,! kP)$0#).! .$3AA$3)0AT! 0'.#0#6%! 9'5a''6!, D34)0!)60!2,!+,!G3*)6!Y7[S8U,!k-3*'!3F!@'./)6#.)*!A5$'AA!#6!.)*.#F#.)5#36! 3F!)3$5#.!9#3($3A5/'5#.!=)*='A,k!h!B/3$).!P)$0#3=)A.!24$%!UQY7UT!77QO7:Q l330!)60!h,!i,!l'99!Y:;78U,!kQO?')$!345.3@'!)F5'$!5$)6A.)5/'5'$!)3$5#.!=)*='!#@(*)65)5#36,k65#6)Om)5'A\77U,!kDAA'AA@'65!3F!5365$)A5! )3$53%$) #6! ()5#'65A! $'F'$$'0!F3$!5$)6A.)5/'5'$!)3$5#.!=)*='!#@(*)65)5#36,k!P)5/'5'$!P)$0#3=)A.!R65'$=!SSYNUT!SNSOS<QX36#A\!D,!I=)6%'*#A5)\!Z,!C)*`\!X,!E46%\!+,!E)6.'**355#\!E,!+#'$)$0\!2,!+$#.'\!e,! h,!2./)F'$A\!i,!2./4*'$\!h,!25'(#6A`)\!H,!2a'09'$%\!h,!B)``'69'$%\!q,!_,!Z36!_(('**\!2,!l#60'.`'$\!h, p.8 ,
!b)6)%'@'65!3F!Z)*=4*)$! e')$5! "#A')A'! 3F! 5, I4$3(')6! DAA3.#)5#36! F3$! P)$0#3OB)%'@'65!3F!=)*=4*)$!/')$5!0#A')A'!Y='$A#36!:h3#65!B)A`!C3$.'!36 ,
$A! )60! h,! h,! B)``'69'$%! Y:;;[U,! k+)5#'65! 3455#@'! )65#.3)%4*)65O$'*)5'0! '='65!$#A`!)%)#6A5!$'3('$)5#36!$#A`,k!h!B/3$))6! 25''69, 3@'! )F5'$! )3$5#.! =)*='! $'(*).'@'65! a#57NU,! kI)$*?! 5$)6A.)5/'5'$!)3$5#.!=)*='!0'%'6'$)5#36!#6!5=3*45#36! 3F! 9#3($3A5/'5#.! /')$5! =)*='! 0'A#%6! )60! #5A! #@().5! 36! 04$)9#*#5?,k! P)$0#3=)A.!+)5/3*!GMYQUT!:<<O:SN6#A@! 3F! 9#3($3A5/'5#.! =)*='! F)#*4$',k!D66!B/3$).!24$%!TQY8UT!8 Y7[[:U,! kb#.$3@'./)6#.A! 3F! 5/'! F#9$3A)! )60! 5/'! ='65$#.4*)$#A! #6! )3$5#.! =)*='!*')F*'5A,k!h!X#3@'./!MNY7UT!7;7O778,! ! ! 7QQ!, pp.60-63 ,
**)%'6! 0'6)54$)5#36! )60! %*?.3A)@#63%*?.)6!*3AA,k!h!X#3@'0!b)5'$! )60! a)5'$O9#3@)5'$#)*! $'*)5#36A/#(A,k! h! X#3@'0!b)5'$*45)$)*0'/?0'OF#J'0! 9#3($3A5!e)66)\!D,!i)6)()5/#\!h,!I,!H''6), '$6'$\! h,! 1,! X)A`#6\! -,! 1)60\! C,! h,! 2./3'6! )60! -,! h,! E'=?! Y7[[SU,! k+$'='65#36! 3F! .)*.#F#.)5#36! 3F! %*45)$)6#A5#.!A540#'A,k!h!e')$5!Z)'0)$0\!b,!X$)#A!)60!l,!h,!H'36!Y7[S<U,!kZ)*='!F)#*4$'!.)4A'0!9?!.4A(!5')$A!#6!*3aO ($3F#*'! R36'A.4O2/#*'?! 93=#6'! ('$#.)$0#)*! 9#3($3A57QU,! kP3@()$#A36! 3F! )3$5#.! )664*4A! A#c'! 9?! 5$)6A'A30#$'.5!A4$%#.)*!@')A4$'@'65,k#F#.)5#36,k!D2DR_!B$)6A!RQY8UT!bL;SOL7;,! l$#%/5\! i,! D,\! h,! b,! C)4%/5! )60! h,! b,! _*#6! Y:;;[U,! kDAA'AA#6%! )65#.)*.#F#.)5#36! 5$')5@'65A! #6! 9#3($3A5/'5#.!5#AA4'!9?!4A#6%!5!$)99#5!#65$)@4A.4*)$!@30'*,k!P3@(!b'0!NaY8UT!:NNO :<7,! m).349\! b X3?*)60\! -,! -)0*6#! )60! D,! b#5./'**!Y7[[QU,!kC34$5''6O?')$!'J('$#'6.'!a#5/!/3@3=#5)*!/3@3%$)F5A!F3$!)3$5#.!=)*='!$'(*).'@'65,k! h!B/3$).!P)$0#3=)A.!24$%!GGVY7UT!7SNO7[8W!0#A.4AA#36!7[8O7SL, p.760 ,